The increased turnover of players in the modern game was highlighted recently by Luke O’Nien breaking Lee Cattermole’s record for the highest number of different Sunderland teammates. In his eight years at the club, Luke has shared the pitch with 149 other players. By contrast, The Lads’ record appearance-maker, Jim Montgomery, played with fewer than a hundred colleagues in his 15-year Wearside career between 1961 and 1976.
This trend has naturally meant that players are spending less time at one club and, consequently, individual appearance and goalscoring records are suffering accordingly.
Advertisement
Only three players (Lee Cattermole, John O’Shea and Luke O’Nien) have reached the 250 first-team game mark this century, whereas seven clocked 250 in the 1990s. Aside from the latter years of the outstanding Kevin Phillips’ career, no player has threatened the 50-goal mark since Niall Quinn reached his half-century against his old club Arsenal in January 2000.

Considering that the big Irishman was the 35th player to score 50 first-team goals for Sunderland, and at least one player had reached the landmark every decade since the club entered the league in 1890, there has to be doubt that anyone will reach that figure again.
The reasons why no player has scored 50 goals for Sunderland in the last 26, going on 27, years are up for debate, but the club’s current operating model will probably ensure that any future prolificacy in front of goal will lead to an early and profitable sale, especially if we stay in the top tier.
Advertisement
Since Quinny’s milestone, the one and only Kevin Phillips, who reached his first 50 goals for Sunderland in 1999, netted another 51 times and remains the club’s highest scorer in the 21st century, despite leaving the club 23 years ago. However, only one other player, Charlie Wyke, has exceeded 40 goals, let alone 50, with the top scorers list since 2000 making rather modest reading:
Kevin Phillips – 51 (nos. 79-130)
Charlie Wyke – 42
Ross Stewart – 40
Marcus Stewart – 39
Jermaine Defoe – 37
Darren Bent – 36
Kenwyne Jones – 28
Jack Clarke – 28
In my humble opinion, the club’s model accounted for the (arguably) premature departures of Clarke and Ross Stewart, and Darren Bent would have reached 50 if he had chosen to stay. Marcus Stewart would probably have bagged a few in the ill-fated 2005/06 season – he couldn’t have done any worse than his replacements. We had the best of Charlie Wyke and Kenwyne, but I feel Jermaine might have had another decent campaign in him if we had stayed up in 2017. Ifs, buts and maybes!
As it stands, and despite not having scored for 18 months, Luke O’Nien remains the club’s overall top scorer (23) and has been for over two years since Jack Clarke’s departure, with our main strikers, Wilson Isidor and Brian Brobbey, on 20 goals and 10 respectively. With goals being hard to come by this season, it would be a (lovely) surprise if those figures rose dramatically any time soon.
Barry Jackson
