Fridays for Future supporters protest in Berlin against climate change on November 13th. Carbon neutrality promises on products are based on the idea that carbon emissions can be offset by capturing and storing carbon. However, recent investigations by ProPublica and Drilled have found that this expectation is not well-founded, with only a small number of large-scale geologic storage projects successful. The reliance on unproven technology is due to the models guiding climate policy, which have already assumed its success. These models, built by influential experts, underpin global commitments to reduce warming. The issue lies in the opacity of climate models, as they don’t document every assumption made in their simulations. I interviewed leaders of three influential models and discovered that they all assume carbon capture to be easy and efficient, despite real capture rates being much lower. Incentives like carbon taxes and government subsidies are factored in, increasing the capture rates. However, these models don’t account for real-world problems, such as injecting CO2 into the earth. They also assume the earth has unlimited geological storage space, despite warnings that this could run out by early next century. Lastly, the models don’t consider the risk of CO2 leaks, which could undermine storage sites’ climate benefits. The models suggest that CCS becomes cheaper over time, despite real-world costs increasing. Strefler believes that if a country is unwilling to invest in CO2 removal now, they’re unlikely to do so in the future. The models overlook several issues, such as underperformance, inflated capture rates, evidence of leaks, and finite underground storage. Van Vuuren’s team is revising some assumptions, but sees no technical reason why CCS can’t work. The models include CCS as a potential solution due to the delay in climate action, leaving few other tools to achieve climate targets. Riahi believes CO2 removal is more likely than alien intervention.
