Opinion: A report the NDP relies on to crow about $1 billion in possible benefits contains key cautionary statements
Article content
VICTORIA — While the New Democrats prepare to release a revised cost estimate for the World Cup in B.C., they continue to claim a reputed $1 billion in benefits from hosting the seven soccer games.
Article content
The latest round in the game of understating costs and overstating benefits was triggered by the recent report from the federal parliamentary budget office on government financial support for hosting the men’s World Cup.
Article content
Article content
Story continues below
Article content
It pegged the cost for all levels of government — federal, provincial, local — at $578 million, or $83 million for each of the seven games here in B.C.
Article content
Article content
The report was immediately discounted by cabinet minister Anne Kang, whose Ministry of Tourism, Arts, Culture and Sport oversees B.C.’s role in hosting the FIFA event.
Article content
She accused the budget watchdog of relying on out-of-date information in drawing conclusions.
Article content
“I would not take the numbers that the PBO has provided as a fact,” Kang told reporters last week. “It was old data that was from last year.”
Article content
Yet the federal office chose from the mid-range of the provincial government’s own cost estimate. This time last year, the province admitted the tab could go as high as $624 million, or almost $90 million a game.
Article content
Kang said the province was working with the federal government, the city and other partners to provide an updated costing before the end of the month.
Article content
Was Kang saying that the revised estimate would be lower than the one in the budget officer’s report?
Article content
No, she wasn’t saying that.
Article content
“When the numbers are released, you will know,” said Kang. “What I would like British Columbians to know is that this is not just a one-time investment on the seven games that we have here, but it is a long-term investment.
Article content
Story continues below
Article content
“In the next five years, we’ll be able to see more than one million more visitors come and more than $1 billion of visitor spending here.”
Article content
Read More
-
Vaughn Palmer: Horgan said Site C sucked, but it would not have happened without him
-
Vaughn Palmer: B.C. NDP relieved as SCC agrees to take DRIPA case
-
Advertisement 1
Story continues below
Article content
The $1 billion claim also figured prominently in Premier David Eby’s most recent defence of FIFA spending, delivered earlier this month at an event marking World Cup related improvements to B.C. Place.
Article content
In light of faltering demand for hotel rooms and tickets for the fan zone, did Eby think the “FIFA juice is worth the squeeze on taxpayers?”
Article content
He did. “Our projections are about a billion dollars of impact.”
Article content
The $1 billion claim derives from a 12 page assessment of the economic impact of the World Cup over the years 2026-31, released in 2024 by B.C. Stats and the tourism ministry.
Article content
The report claimed that the World Cup would deliver a $1 billion boost in retail sales and provincial GDP over the next five years. It also forecast that one million additional visitors would come to B.C. over the same period as a result of the province hosting seven soccer games.
Article content
While the New Democrats seized on those numbers — $1 billion in sales! One million visitors! — they ignored cautionary passages in the report.
