In early October, a recent law school graduate, Preston Bigley, shared on LinkedIn about his new role as an Assistant United States Attorney in the Criminal Division of the U.S. Attorney’s Office for the Western District of Texas. He had been hired by the Justice Department in August, despite being an “incoming” assistant U.S. attorney pending bar admission. Bigley is part of a growing group of inexperienced attorneys being fast-tracked to replace seasoned prosecutors who left or were dismissed from the DOJ during Trump’s second term. This has led to a loss of thousands of years of experience. Over 50 new assistant U.S. attorneys with less than three years of experience have been appointed to key positions, a significant departure from previous hiring practices. The DOJ has long hired recent graduates through its Honors Program, which places graduates into rigorous training through the main office in Washington, but experts say the program was small and not meant to replace prosecutors.. Before Trump’s second term, the DOJ typically would not hire new prosecutors unless they had a minimum of three to five years of legal experience, former officials and law professors said. That standard is gone. Earlier this year, Bloomberg Law reported, the DOJ waived a policy requiring at least one year of experience.. While private law firms routinely hire promising graduates before they pass the bar exam, typically to begin their training, the DOJ’s hiring of new grads is a striking departure from its once-rigorous hiring process, said University of Michigan law professor Barbara McQuade, a former U.S. attorney for the Eastern District of Michigan.. “The people who I hired came to us as partners in law firms,” said McQuade, who was appointed by President Barack Obama. “These were superstars who had been very successful at large law firms or in state court prosecutors’ offices.”. Trump’s creation of a less experienced DOJ will have longstanding consequences, McQuade said.. “It means that some very serious crimes will go unpunished,” she said. “It takes experienced prosecutors at the federal level to bring down corporate fraud, transnational gangs and corrupt public officials.”. While experts expressed concern, some of those benefiting from the law school-to-federal prosecutor pathway have voiced excitement on LinkedIn. “I look forward to beginning my DOJ career by serving the Del Rio Division,” wrote Jacquelyn Kilcommons, who graduated from Pace University’s law school in May. “Upon receiving my bar exam results, I will transition into an Assistant United States Attorney (AUSA) position.”. As he announced his new role in the district of Washington, D.C., newly graduated assistant U.S. attorney Ellis O’Donnell wrote, “In the past few months I have had the honor to graduate from Vanderbilt University Law School and to sit for and pass the Wisconsin Bar Exam. ” None of the recent law school graduates responded to requests for comment.. Shifting Personnel, Shifting Caseloads. The departure of assistant U.S. attorneys in Trump’s second administration marks the largest number of exits two years into a presidential term in at least two decades.. Beyond the personnel turnover, the administration’s priorities have shifted since Trump retook the White House, an analysis of Federal Judicial Center data shows.. As immigration cases shot up nationwide, felony fraud prosecutions fell sharply in key districts. Amid an exodus of prosecutors in the Western District of Virginia, for instance, fraud cases fell 66%. Those cases dropped 14% in the Southern District of Florida, a hotbed for white-collar crime, where many prosecutors have left in protest of Trump’s retribution campaign against people deemed political enemies. Nationally, drug prosecutions have fallen about 10% in Trump’s first 18 months and fraud cases are flat.. Meanwhile, the number of people facing immigration-related charges skyrocketed by almost 50%, clogging the courts and depleting resources at U.S. attorneys’ offices nationwide. Even in border districts where immigration proceedings can dominate the caseload, prosecutions have risen dramatically. For instance, New Mexico and the Southern District of California saw 300% and 125% increases in immigration cases, respectively, the ProPublica analysis shows. In the Western District of Texas, where Bigley and at least two other recent graduates just became prosecutors, immigration cases have surged at least 36%.. The immigration caseload, including tens of thousands of unlawful-detention cases filed in civil court, has strained the department so severely that the DOJ has drafted hundreds of attorneys from other federal agencies and the military to keep up, former officials said.. Those cases coincided with violent deportation sweeps led by masked immigration agents, who killed U.S. citizens, and the nationwide protests that sprouted up in response. A ProPublica investigation has revealed that many cases brought by Trump’s DOJ against individuals protesting immigration authorities’ actions collapsed. The news organization also highlighted concerns about the honesty of Trump’s prosecutors in courts across the country. The DOJ previously stated its attorneys “represent the United States with integrity.” ProPublica has tracked nearly 100,000 habeas corpus petitions filed by immigrants arguing that their detentions were unjust. In each case, an assistant U.S. attorney must defend the government’s position, leading to some U.S. attorneys reassigning experienced lawyers to immigration cases. In Washington state, an acting U.S. attorney claimed his office was too busy with unlawful-detention petitions to handle every case. In South Florida, where a drop in fraud and financial crime cases was anticipated due to an exodus of veteran lawyers, a former white-collar crimes prosecutor said he and his colleagues could not decline an immigration case without permission from U.S. Attorney Jason Reding Quiñones, who resigned this month. The DOJ has since increased efforts to recruit lawyers to replace the lost expertise. A month later, the University of Miami organized an event named “Lunch & Learn: Entry Level Opportunities with The U.S. Attorney’s Office,” aimed at third-year law students, offering a new pathway to become a criminal prosecutor in one of the busiest districts in the country. The U.S. Attorney’s Office for the Southern District of Florida is now recruiting 3Ls for entry-level positions starting immediately after graduation, an exciting expansion of opportunities for Miami Law students interested in federal prosecution. To attract new hires, the DOJ is offering signing bonuses. As of August, the department’s ranks increased to about 5,600, a 10% drop from the end of the Biden administration. U.S. Rep. Jamie Raskin, the ranking member on the House Judiciary Committee, observed that the shift towards inexperience is evident in courtrooms across the country. He suspects the department’s loss of financial crime experts like him will result in fewer successful prosecutions.. “It’s a good time to be a white-collar criminal,” Fang said.. Now facing off against his former colleagues, he’s mostly busy representing clients who’ve filed habeas petitions. He was recently surprised to learn that one of the new hires brought into his former office had just passed the bar. “They’re taking a gamble on them,” he said.. Fang says they may well end up being fine attorneys but added, “There’s no way I could have taken that job and done it well right out of law school.”. How We Quantified Changes to Trump’s Justice Department. To measure changes at the Department of Justice under the second Trump administration, we analyzed federal workforce data from the Office of Personnel Management and the Federal Judicial Center’s Integrated Database, which tracks federal court cases.. To measure turnover among assistant U.S. attorneys, we counted the number of attorneys who were compensated under the “Administratively Determined” pay scale within the Executive Office for United States Attorneys and the United States Attorneys’ Offices (OPM Code: DJ09). To estimate years of legal experience, we used experience ranges associated with AD pay grades. Our workforce analysis covers January 2025 through August 2026.. To analyze court cases, we looked at the number of defendants charged in federal court during the roughly 18 months since Trump took office, from Jan. 20, 2025, through June 30, 2026, the most recent data available. We compared that with a period of the same length (527 days) during the end of the Biden administration. Each defendant was counted once. We counted only their most severe charge as ranked by the Federal Judicial Center. We also compared the last six quarters of Biden’s term with the first six quarters of 2025 and 2026 and found similar results.. We grouped charges into broader categories using a classification system developed by the Administrative Office of the U.S. Courts. Our fraud category includes embezzlement and forgery. We counted the “Nationality Laws” category, which the AOUSC groups with fraud, as immigration. We also counted two other types of charges as immigration offenses: failing to report arrival into the United States (19 USC 1459) and, in the districts of New Mexico, Western Texas and Arizona, entering military-designated national defense areas along the border (50 USC 797).
