Close Menu
    What's Hot

    Whiteford rolls to spot in state finals, Jefferson falls in semis

    November 21, 2026

    Prairie View A&M clinches spot in SWAC championship game with rout of Alabama State

    November 21, 2026

    Mike McCarthy Reveals Biggest Key vs. Eagles

    November 21, 2026
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram Threads
    TheBullPost
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram
    Subscribe
    • International
    • Politics
    • Crime
    • Economy
    • Sports
    • Entertainment
      • Music
      • Movie
      • Gaming
      • Literature
    • continents
      • Africa
      • America
      • Asia
      • Australia
      • Europe
    • Tech
    • Top Trending
    • Editor’s Pick
    • Lifestyle
      • Fashion
      • food
      • Health
      • Travel
    TheBullPost
    Home»Business»The Moral Crisis of Social Security​
    Business

    The Moral Crisis of Social Security​

    soreceryBy soreceryNovember 20, 2026No Comments11 Mins Read
    Share
    Facebook Twitter Pinterest Threads Bluesky Copy Link

    ​

    “Society is indeed a contract. … It is a partnership in all science; a partnership in all art; a partnership in every virtue, and in all perfection. As the ends of such a partnership cannot be obtained in many generations, it becomes a partnership not only between those who are living, but between those who are living, those who are dead, and those who are to be born.”
    – Edmund Burke, The Selected Works of Edmund Burke vol. 2: Reflections on the Revolution in France

    In the 236 years since Burke penned those words, that partnership increasingly resembles a conflict over the obligations inherited from the past and passed onto the future. Nowhere is this more apparent than in Social Security’s Old Age and Survivors Insurance (OASI). Retirees have organized their lives around promised benefits while younger workers finance those benefits and face uncertainty about their own future. As demographic and financial pressures intensify, the program creates competing claims between generations. 

    Social Security’s designers bear responsibility for creating a system that rewards demands for benefits while passing substantial costs to younger and future taxpayers. Politicians gain support by promising payments while organized beneficiaries defend transfers financed by others. Successive generations have inherited both the bill and the incentives to enlarge it.

    Acknowledging that responsibility does not settle what we should do now. Any sustainable reform must account for competing interests and dependence on inherited institutions. Condemning our predecessors does not bring us any closer to financing benefits or assembling a coalition for change.

    The Burkean understanding of societal partnership paired with public choice theory offers a way to support a gradual transition. Cohort separation would protect those with little time to adjust while moving younger and future workers toward privately owned retirement savings. The inherited bill would still require explicit financing. Our responsibility is to find a politically feasible way to discharge obligations to the elderly while changing the rules that encourage the present generation to pass more costs onto the future.

    Burke and Buchanan

    Burke understood that inherited institutions create obligations that must be considered before those institutions are changed. In Reflections, he explains that inheritance permits conservation and transmission without excluding improvement. The living receive institutions from their predecessors, preserve what remains valuable, and pass them to their successors. 

    No single generation possesses unlimited authority to dispose of that inheritance, which is why Burke calls the living “the temporary possessors and life-renters.” He warns against leaving successors with “a ruin instead of an habitation” while not mistaking continuity for immobility. Michael Oakeshott similarly describes tradition as a “living language,” sustained by “its elasticity and its ability to suffer change without disruption.”

    In A Letter to a Noble Lord (February 1796), Burke distinguished reform from change that destroys an institution’s essential purpose, hoping that statesmen could correct the institutional defects while preserving what made that institution valuable. 

    Burke’s intergenerational partnership supplies a standard for judging Social Security’s development. The living have inherited institutions, but they don’t have unlimited authority to burden their successors by demanding every claim be preserved. Political coalitions that expand benefits while postponing the financing violate that duty of stewardship. Social Security’s predicament reflects choices for which its designers and defenders bear responsibility.

    James M. Buchanan clarifies the financing problem. Borrowing separates the benefits of spending from the taxes needed to service the debt. The people receiving benefits and bearing taxes need not be the same. Public investment may benefit future taxpayers, but political rules must make its financing visible. Scheduled OASI benefits differ from Treasury debt, but the same questions about who benefits, who pays, and how these unfunded obligations affect behavior remain.

    We have also inherited the consequences of those choices. Roughly 25 million American seniors live in households that receive at least half their income from Social Security, and they have little time to replace it. Their dependence does not vindicate the arrangements that created it, but it matters when deciding how to reform them. Burke’s relevance lies in this two-fold obligation: correct an inherited wrong while exercising prudence toward those caught within it. Cohort separation seeks to meet that obligation by explicitly financing inherited commitments while changing the system for the future.

    Social Security and Generational Conflict

    The program’s expansion began long before most of today’s retirees could vote. Since it came into existence, the program has faced pressure for broader benefits. In 1939, Congress added dependent and survivor benefits, increased early benefits, and brought the start of monthly payments forward by two years, allowing them to begin in 1940 instead of 1942. 

    My friend Aidan Grogan wrote earlier this year of an American gerontocracy, “a political and economic system under the leadership of the elderly,” where Boomers “take care of their own and make younger Americans foot the bill for their longer and more luxurious retirements.” Grogan’s frustration echoes Yale law professor Samuel Moyn’s concern that an aging electorate is shaping economic and political outcomes in its favor. 

    This conflict reflects the way Social Security relies on pay-as-you-go financing. This approach uses the payroll taxes of younger workers to pay today’s beneficiaries. The federal government has even admitted that the “trust fund” is a misnomer, considering that there are no assets that can be drawn upon to pay benefits. Instead, the “trust fund” represents claims on specially issued treasury notes “that, when redeemed, will have to be financed by raising taxes, borrowing from the public, or reducing benefits or other expenditures.”

    As the population ages, fewer workers support each beneficiary. That demographic pressure makes existing promises harder to finance without higher taxes or adjustments elsewhere. 

    With benefits projected to be depleted by 2032, closing the gap forces a choice as to who bears the adjustment. Higher payroll taxes burden workers, benefit reductions burden retirees and those about to retire, and general revenues compete with other budget priorities. Borrowing postpones some immediate adjustments, but it diverts capital away from private investment and does not eliminate the cost.

    These pressures, however, have not deterred policymakers from expanding promised benefits. The Social Security Fairness Act, signed in January 2025, repealed provisions that reduced benefits for certain people receiving pensions from employment outside Social Security. 

    The generational conflict is genuine, but that does not make any generation selfish, or show that spending on the elderly is always unjust. Instead, it shows why promises must be weighed against competing claims against resources.

    Political incentives explain the current impasse. Retirees have strong incentives to defend the benefits they have been promised and have incorporated into their retirement plans. Working Americans have incentive to resist higher taxes while preserving their own expected retirement income. Politicians, who want to get reelected, have incentives to avoid changes that immediately anger either group. All the while, future generations have no votes to offer and no representatives they can hold accountable.

    The transition’s hardest objection remains: younger Americans would still help support existing beneficiaries while saving for themselves, carrying two obligations at once.

    Most voters have limited incentives to master the complex system of government finances while groups with substantial financial interest in a program have stronger incentives to monitor legislation and influence lawmakers. That dynamic makes reforms with immediate costs and distant benefits difficult to enact.

    Consequently, lawmakers debate long-term financing while postponing the changes needed to resolve the problem.

    Where Burke supplies a moral standard for honoring the partnership between generations, public choice theory explains why political decisions fail to live up to it. It also suggests how different rules might improve that cooperation.

    Buchanan’s work on constitutional political economy is particularly helpful. Institutions rely on “relatively absolute absolutes” or rules that are stable enough for people to organize their lives around them yet open to examination, criticism, and revision. 

    People may accept a rule system that restrains their own political demands in exchange for predictable rules that allow for cooperation and mutual gains. Preserving that cooperation, however, requires occasionally revisiting and revising such arrangements to prevent imposing unsustainable costs. 

    Retirees and near-retirees have organized their golden years around Social Security’s existing system. Abrupt changes, especially for middle and high earners, will feel like a rug pull deserving of a political punishment. Protecting retirement security, however, does not require every future worker to enter the same system.

    Honoring the Past Without Mortgaging the Future

    Cohort separation would phase in changes by birth year, protecting established expectations for retirees and near-retirees. Meanwhile, younger workers would keep recognition of benefits attributable to past covered earnings while building funded accounts. Future entrants would save through privately owned accounts. Gradual phase-ins would soften the cutoff between adjacent birth years but exact ages, contribution rates, and financing would require actuarial estimates.

    Congress could also examine voluntary buyouts of part of future OASI benefits, paid into privately owned retirement accounts. Some retirees might prefer control over assets or the ability to leave an inheritance. Retirees with other resources could honor the Burkean partnership by accepting less than the expected cost of the benefits surrendered, voluntarily lightening the obligations passed onto future taxpayers. Any offer would require explicit financing and protection for spouses and survivors. Savings would depend on the benefits surrendered by those who accept; people expecting shorter lives could be especially willing to exchange future payments for cash. Borrowing to fund an actuarially equivalent buyout, however, will still place a burden on future taxpayers.

    As I wrote earlier this year, it is particularly difficult to decide who gets to stay in the old system. Elected officials may worry about drawing the ire of those voters who barely miss the cutoff and weaken or abandon any proposed reforms. An independent commission, such as the BRAC Social Security commission proposed by Romina Boccia, may be able to navigate such concerns, minimizing the political backlash against Congress. Boccia’s model is based on the commission of the same name where independent experts would develop a package for presidential approval and default implementation unless Congress blocked it through a joint resolution of disapproval. Preventing amendments or ad hoc changes would help protect the changes from being unraveled.

    These phase-ins could move future workers toward another recommendation by Boccia and many others: a flat benefit that provides basic support in old age. A reformed system could pair this flat benefit with individual accounts. This redesign could better achieve the initial 1935 goal: preventing the elderly from suffering terribly from “the vicissitudes of life.”

     Any legacy commitments would be funded through general revenues with the necessary tax increases or spending reductions clearly identified. Recognizing the liability, however, would not pay the bill on its own. Linking retirement claims to accumulated assets could reduce dependence on future taxpayers. That outcome depends on actual saving and credible ownership rules.

    The transition’s hardest objection remains: younger Americans would still help support existing beneficiaries while saving for themselves, carrying two obligations at once. Their account contributions would purchase assets they own, but the pressure on current income would still feel substantial. Congress should show the expected burden by cohort. Additionally, turning these costs into general revenue obligations would require spending reductions or tax increases on all Americans. 

    Nonetheless, younger workers would still be asked to bear costs they did not choose. The costs of cohort separation, however, must be compared with both timely reforms of the existing system and the consequences of ignoring the current flaws.

    Longer life expectancy and improved health must also mean a reevaluation of what retirement looks like. While health and job demands can make that impossible for some seniors, tax rules should reward those who do choose to return to work. After full retirement age, earnings no longer reduce Social Security benefits, but payroll taxes remain and additional earnings can make more benefits taxable. Congress could index the benefit taxation thresholds and reduce the extra tax triggered as benefits become taxable. Any lost revenue would need explicit financing.

    Reforms should also widen private alternatives. Equalizing contribution limits for individually owned accounts and workplace plans would make saving less dependent on an employer’s benefits. Civic associations could help members save and obtain lifetime annuities, which fraternal societies such as The Knights of Columbus already offer. Voluntary assistance can complement these arrangements for those unable to work or save enough. Strengthening these institutions would give the intergenerational partnership practical expression beyond government budgets.

    What the Living Leave Behind

    We cannot reverse past decisions about Social Security, but we can choose whether to preserve the incentives that produced them. 

    The task is to protect people who rely on existing arrangements, distribute inherited costs transparently, and establish rules that make future retirement promises harder to detach from their financing. That requires rules that constrain unfunded promises and deferring costs. We must also appreciate that change is inevitable, so these rules must be open to criticism and improvements so that reforms can be made long after we are gone.

    We owe those who came before us fidelity and we owe those who will come after us prudence.

      ​​

    Share this:

    • Share on X (Opens in new window) X
    • Share on Facebook (Opens in new window) Facebook

    Like this:

    Like Loading…
    Share. Facebook Twitter Pinterest Bluesky Threads Tumblr Telegram Email
    Unknown's avatar
    sorecery
    • Website

    Related Posts

    The Penny Is Dead. Now It’s Official.

    November 21, 2026

    The Used Car Industry Is Booming. This N.J. Campus Is Setting the Price.

    November 21, 2026

    William Nordhaus’s Contributions to Economics—and His Blind Spot​

    November 20, 2026
    Add A Comment
    Leave A Reply Cancel Reply

    Economy News

    Whiteford rolls to spot in state finals, Jefferson falls in semis

    By soreceryNovember 21, 2026

    Advertisement Advertisement Advertisement Advertisement Breaking News Michigan hands No. 4 UCLA its first loss Read…

    Share this:

    • Share on X (Opens in new window) X
    • Share on Facebook (Opens in new window) Facebook

    Like this:

    Like Loading…

    Prairie View A&M clinches spot in SWAC championship game with rout of Alabama State

    November 21, 2026

    Mike McCarthy Reveals Biggest Key vs. Eagles

    November 21, 2026
    Top Trending

    Whiteford rolls to spot in state finals, Jefferson falls in semis

    By soreceryNovember 21, 2026

    Advertisement Advertisement Advertisement Advertisement Breaking News Michigan hands No. 4 UCLA its…

    Share this:

    • Share on X (Opens in new window) X
    • Share on Facebook (Opens in new window) Facebook

    Like this:

    Like Loading…

    Prairie View A&M clinches spot in SWAC championship game with rout of Alabama State

    By soreceryNovember 21, 2026

    Advertisement Advertisement Advertisement Advertisement Breaking News Michigan hands No. 4 UCLA its…

    Share this:

    • Share on X (Opens in new window) X
    • Share on Facebook (Opens in new window) Facebook

    Like this:

    Like Loading…

    Mike McCarthy Reveals Biggest Key vs. Eagles

    By soreceryNovember 21, 2026

    Advertisement Advertisement Advertisement Advertisement Breaking News Michigan hands No. 4 UCLA its…

    Share this:

    • Share on X (Opens in new window) X
    • Share on Facebook (Opens in new window) Facebook

    Like this:

    Like Loading…
    Advertisement
    TheBullPost
    • About
    • Privacy Policy
    • Contact us
    • Terms of Service: The Bull Post
    © 2026 The Bull Post. Designed by Sorecery.

    Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.

    %d