
Article content
In the days before the recent U.S. midterm elections, we were treated to mixed trade messages. U.S. President Donald Trump told Fox News, “We’re going to make a deal with Canada very soon. We’re going to make a great deal.” Meanwhile, on the U.S. news outlet Politico, Prime Minister Mark Carney said, “Canada is prepared to wait until a new U.S. president takes office rather than rush into a trade agreement under unfavourable terms with U.S. President Trump.”
Article content
Advertisement 1
Story continues below
Article content
It is clear that trade negotiations had been intensifying over the past weeks. What has been less clear is where this is leading us. In the wake of midterm results, two distinct options seem to be emerging for Canada. One argues that Canada should try to land an acceptable trade deal now given that the Trump administration is on the ropes. Another suggests Canada should wait out the rest of Trump’s term and resume negotiations with a new administration that might be more supportive of the spirit and letter of the Canada-U.S.-Mexico trade agreement (CUSMA). If posed as hockey analogies, what would we choose: “sudden death overtime” or “ragging the puck”? The answer is — it depends. It depends on what version of the Democratic party shows up to take over Congress in January.
Article content
Article content
Article content
Both options assume that a Democrat-controlled Congress will clip Trump’s protectionist wings and force a rollback of his waves of tariffs. Affordability was the defining domestic issue in the midterms. In a September survey, the U.S.-based Cato Institute found that 75 per cent of respondents thought Trump’s tariffs had increased domestic household prices. Over half thought the tariffs had weakened the U.S. economy. On Nov. 3, the ballot box delivered a pretty clear mandate for Democrats to address affordability challenges like tariffs. What is not clear is exactly how they intend to act and whether they can restrain Trump’s exercise of executive authority under which all of his extraordinary tariffs have been invoked.
Article content
Advertisement 2
Story continues below
Article content
Before examining this, let’s set the stage with a brief recap on where we’re at on tariffs and trade talks.
Article content
Trump’s tariffs have descended on Canada in waves over the past two years — with the largest delivering sectoral tariffs ranging from 10 per cent to 50 per cent on our exports of softwood lumber, autos, steel and aluminum. Some earlier tariffs have been struck down by the U.S. Supreme Court only to be replaced by tariffs invoked under other emergency authorities allegedly within the president’s ambit. In August, Trump imposed tariffs of up to 50 per cent on $27.6 billion of Canadian exports. Canada reciprocated in September with dollar-for-dollar tariffs on a range of U.S. exports. Since then, both countries have switched up their hit lists, adding products in, taking others out. Trump has said he would increase current sectoral tariffs on automobiles and steel to 50 per cent on Jan. 1, but nothing has been seen on this beyond a Truth Social post.
Article content
Canada remains the only country outside of China that is actively retaliating against U.S. tariffs. Yet, through all of this, CUSMA remains in place. The U.S. has not given Canada and Mexico the required six-month notice of its intent to withdraw from the treaty. So, surprisingly, despite rounds of retaliation, CUSMA still affords duty-free treatment to over 80 per cent of Canada’s exports to the U.S. Is your head spinning yet?
