
Article content
The message from Vancouver voters is clear. They want less drug use in public spaces — more than 68 per cent voted in favour of strengthening laws to prohibit open-air hard drug use in the city’s recent plebiscite.
Article content
The frustration is understandable. No one wants to see people using drugs on sidewalks, in parks or outside businesses. Many residents who supported the plebiscite were expressing legitimate concerns about safety and the condition of public spaces.
Article content
Article content
Advertisement 1
Story continues below
Article content
The question is not whether change is needed. It is what kind of response is most likely to achieve it.
Article content
Article content
If we are serious about reducing visible drug use, we need to consider why it occurs. Public drug use is a symptom of deeper challenges, including poverty, homelessness, substance dependence, and a toxic illicit drug supply.
Article content
It is tempting to believe tougher law enforcement is the answer. Yet police are often among the first to acknowledge that they are not equipped to solve poverty and drug dependence. Enforcement can move people from one block to another, but displacement is not the same as solving the problem.
Article content
If someone is using drugs in public because they are struggling with substance dependency and have nowhere private to go, how will arresting them and releasing them into the same conditions help?
Article content
Policing is also expensive, consuming police, court and correctional resources when the criminal justice system is already under significant strain.
Article content
Some critics may argue that visible drug use is the result of Vancouver becoming too permissive. But while it may be tempting to blame a lack of enforcement, the evidence points elsewhere.
Article content
Advertisement 2
Story continues below
Article content
Research conducted in Vancouver has consistently found that unstable housing and lack of access to private spaces are among the strongest predictors of public drug use. Studies have also found that many people who spend significant time in open drug markets would be willing to relocate if they had access to alternative spaces. This should not be surprising. People without stable housing or private places to spend time are far more likely to rely on public spaces.
Article content
So what would a more effective response look like?
Article content
In the long term, Vancouver needs a serious commitment to reducing poverty and homelessness. Expanding affordable and supportive housing would address key conditions contributing to visible public drug use.
Article content
In the shorter term, people need alternatives to using drugs on sidewalks and in parks. If the goal is to move drug use out of public spaces, people need somewhere else to go. Supervised consumption services can provide alternative environments while connecting people with health care, treatment options and other supports.
Article content
We also need to recognize that much of the suffering we see on Vancouver’s streets is being driven by a toxic drug supply contaminated with fentanyl and potent sedatives. Providing regulated alternatives that separate people from fentanyl and potent sedatives in street drugs could help stabilize people and create opportunities to connect them with health and social services. If implemented at a meaningful scale, regulated alternatives to street drugs could significantly reduce the disorder and distress residents encounter in public spaces.
