57 years. That’s the last time Columbia beat a Big Ten team.
But on Monday night in Welsh-Ryan Arena, that streak finally ended in devastating fashion for the Wildcats.
A 75-53 loss ended that decades-long streak and set off early-season alarm bells for the Wildcats. The Lions led by as many as 26 late in the game, and it was the second straight loss by more than 20 points, dropping the team to 3-2 early in the season.
Advertisement
“It’s hard to find any silver linings, really,” head coach Chris Collins said postgame. “Just a little bit shocked, a little bit stunned by how we played tonight. But it’s kind of who we are right now.”
With little margin for error, NU couldn’t play with force against a team it were projected to handle with ease.
The numbers show the clearest picture. Northwestern had taken just six free throws all game, while Columbia took four times as many. The Lions also grabbed 38.7% of their own misses, yielding a 15-8 edge in second-chance points. Seven Columbia players finished with at least three rebounds, including guard Hampton Sanders, who grabbed six despite being listed at 6-foot, though Collins guessed he’s “maybe 5-foot-9”.
“It was not just their bigger bodies,” Collins said. “It was a collection of their mindset of playing with physicality, and we just don’t have it right now. We’re getting beat to balls, we’re getting pushed under the rim, it’s guards, it’s bigs, it’s everybody.”
Advertisement
Losing size hasn’t helped that cause. Collins said the team will be without redshirt junior Ryan Soulis for an indefinite period due to a foot injury that requires surgery, alongside redshirt junior Luke McEldon, taking a leave of absence. Without them, Northwestern has played 6-foot-9 junior Okku Federiko at center, who’s only played power forward at the collegiate level.
Collins didn’t make excuses, saying the absences didn’t explain the rebounding issue.
“It’s not an excuse with having guys out,” he said. “It’s a mindset.”
Despite offensive struggles to start, Northwestern still the lead 13 minutes into Monday’s contest. Angelo Ciaravino sank a jumper with 7:20 left in the first half that put the ‘Cats up 17-11. But while Northwestern’s struggles lingered in the first half, Columbia started to surge. The Lions closed the half on a 17-2 run and led 28-19 after 20 minutes. The Wildcats shot 7-of-27 from the field and 1-for-11 from deep. Collins said the team got a lot of open looks but missed many, which affected the team’s energy.
Advertisement
“I thought our heads got down a little bit,” he said.
After halftime, Northwestern tightened the gap to five points, but Columbia answered each time. Gerard O’Keefe scored 14 of his game-high 20 points in the half, shooting 5-for-6 inside the arc. Collins said the defense broke down during that span, ignored its gameplan and allowed the Lions to find easy layups.
Columbia also had an effective plan for guarding Jake West, who had scored 20+ points in every game up until Monday, by trapping him on ball screens and forcing another Wildcat to beat them. West finished with just nine points on 4-of-12 shooting, along with four assists and three turnovers. He was blunt about the source of the team’s struggles after the game.
“This loss is on me,” West said. “I got to be better. I got to be more mature as a player.”
Advertisement
Collins took the blame himself. “I got to do a better job. My staff has to do a better job of trying to be competitive with what we have right now.”
Northwestern’s schedule gives them little time to make adjustments. The Wildcats head to Charleston, South Carolina, for their first away game of the year against their first Power Five team, Virginia Tech, on Wednesday and then again that Friday against Dayton. Asked whether they’ll be able to recover from the disappointing start, Collins sounded more exasperated than he did assured.
“I mean, if so, we should just cancel the games,” he said. “We have to get better. We got to play better…I’m not ready to cancel the season yet.”
Whether Northwestern can find that edge will be answered in Charleston, and it will say a lot more about where the season is headed from here.
