Watch: ‘Love Island USA’ Season 9 Confirmed With Ariana Madix Returning as Host
There’s still love between Melanie Moreno and Kenzie Annis.
The season eight Islanders hashed out their differences at Love Island USA‘s Aug. 31 reunion hosted by Ariana Madix and Andy Cohen, revealing what went wrong after Fiji, starting with when Kenzie was heard calling season eight “the Melanie show” during a livestream.
“After watching the show back, I did see that she did get a lot more air time,” Kenzie reiterated of the moment. “But I would never talk s–t about her. I don’t think that that is talking s–t.”
Kenzie also told Melanie that during the show, “I was always there for you.”
For her part, Melanie took issue with how she became a topic of conversation when she wasn’t present.
“It just caught me off guard that everyone’s together, and that is even a conversation,” the model expressed. “I have not done anything to you.”
“I feel like these little comments that I’m hearing don’t add up to me,” Melanie continued, adding of Kenzie’s support, “Even watching the show back, I’ve never seen it.”
She also pointed to Kenzie’s boyfriend Dylan Wrona‘s social media activity, including his alleged liking of a post referring to Melanie, Aniya Harvey and Kayda Bosse as “birds.”
“I see you liking stuff saying that we’re bullying her,” Melanie explained. “We never bullied you, Kenzie.”
But after talking through their differences, both women admitted the chances of reconciliation weren’t over.
“I still love her,” the Georgia native confessed. “I feel like she’s like my sister. So it hurts that she’s hurt by it.”
Melanie agreed, “Right now I really just want a friendship where we pour into each other outside of that crazy environment.”
Indeed, the one-on-one was a long time coming thanks to rumors of a fallout triggered by Kenzie seemingly unfollowing Melanie on Instagram. Around the same time, Kenzie first acknowledged the comment about Melanie’s screen time on a July 15 episode of Call Her Daddy.
Viewers first watched Melanie and Kenzie discuss their relationship during season eight episode 29, when Kenzie took issue with Melanie and partner Sincere Rhea voting for her in an elimination.
Photo by: Ben Symons/Peacock via Getty Images
“I was like ‘Melanie’s my best friend here,'” the 24-year-old noted. “‘I’m not even putting her on a [chopping] block next.'”
Still Melanie, also 24, countered that she no longer felt close to the dancer.
“I don’t feel like we talk that much anymore,” Melanie admitted. “When you even called me your best friend, I just felt like I’m your best friend, but it never felt like you were my best friend.”
And the rift began when Kenzie got to know bombshell Sol Dean amid her flirtation with Sincere, Melanie said.
Photo by: Ben Symons/Peacock via Getty Images
“I felt when Sol was here, and it was the Sincere, Sol and me situation, all I ever saw was you being with Sol,” the Philly native continued. “Which is cool you were friends, but you never checked up on me.”
After explaining she was trying to be there for Sol during a “really hard time,” Kenzie admitted she regretted not being more supportive.
“I’m sorry I made you feel that way,” Kenzie shared through tears. “Because I do want to be there for you.”
Read on for all the secrets behind how Love Island comes to life each summer.
Ben Symons/Peacock via Getty Images
Ben Symons/Peacock via Getty Images
Ben Symons/Peacock via Getty Images
Ben Symons/Peacock via Getty Images
Jeff Spicer/BAFTA/Getty Images
Ben Symons/Peacock via Getty Images
Ben Symons/Peacock via Getty Images
Ben Symons/Peacock
Adam Torgerson/CBS via Getty Images
Lila Seeley/PEACOCK via Getty Images
Ben Symons/Peacock via Getty Images
Ben Symons/Peacock via Getty Images
Ben Symons/Peacock via Getty Images
ITV/Shutterstock
ITV/Shutterstock
ITV/Shutterstock
For the latest breaking news updates, click here to download the E! News App
