If anyone has earned the right to weigh in on clubhouse culture, leadership and a manager’s role in maintaining discipline, it’s David Cone. He’s currently the YES Network’s star analyst, but his knowledge was acquired through years in the trenches.
No one knows New York baseball like Cone. He lived in both universes during a 17-year career, including parts of six seasons with the Mets at their wildest (1987-92) and another six with the Yankees at their peak (1995-2000).
Advertisement
Those experiences have given Cone a credible voice on the Yankees’ most critical issues:
How much are general manager Brian Cashman and manager Aaron Boone to blame for the ongoing championship drought? Do the Yankees need tougher leadership? And what about the scathing indictments from several former Yankees who say the 2026 team lacked an edge?
Cone began a lengthy interview on Monday by taking exception to those former Yankees, some of whom were his teammates, for taking uninformed shots at the present-day clubhouse. The list of critics included CC Sabathia, Jorge Posada, Anthony Rizzo and Alex Rodriguez.
“I find it really hard to criticize when you’re not in the middle of it, when you’re not in that clubhouse,” Cone said. “It’s easy to take shots when you’re on the outside looking in. We don’t know for sure what goes on behind those closed doors.
Advertisement
“It’s a bit surprising hearing all that because ex-players should know better than anyone else. Unless you’re inside the clubhouse, then you really don’t know what’s going on. The ex-players need to be more specific. You need to come with receipts. I’m a broadcaster who covers this team, and even I don’t know what (Aaron) Judge says to Jazz Chisholm. That’s why I’m very reluctant to be critical of the way they handle their business.”
Cone freely admits he’s kept a distance from the current generation of Yankees. His professional life is now in the booth — he rarely visits the clubhouse. Cone, who won a Cy Young Award with the Royals in 1994 and threw a perfect game with the Yankees in 1999, has fully transitioned to a media career.
He’s won five New York Emmy Awards for his sharp analysis on the YES Network. But Cone doesn’t pretend to be a club insider. He’s respected by the players and staff — friendly with Boone and Judge alike — but by no means is he anyone’s pal.
That neutrality allows Cone to say fans have a right to be frustrated going into 2027, even as he takes an unpopular position on Cashman and Boone. He praises both, especially the manager.
Advertisement
“I think Aaron Boone is outstanding at what he does,” Cone said. “His personality is well-suited for the modern-day managerial position. Now, if you want to critique him in his post-game (press conferences) and say, ‘I wish we’d see a little more of this or a little more of that,’ that’s certainly fair.
“Maybe you’d like to see a little less protectiveness of the players. But if you’re a player, you love that. That’s probably why the players really do love him. But there’s always a shelf life. It’s hard to be a manager, especially nowadays.
“Boone is coming up on close to 10 years with the Yankees, where he’s the spokesman. He’s the guy you hear before the games, after the game. You hear the same sort of things over and over, and the shelf life kind of gets to you a little bit.
“As a fan, you need, you want to hear something different. That’s not a knock. That’s just the nature of the game.”
Advertisement
Cone is aware that Boone is a good person who, by some fans, is perceived as too permissive for a team that’s weak on fundamentals. But Cone expresses two counterarguments, both in Boone’s favor.
First, Cone argues Boone couldn’t pull off the tough-guy act even if he tried.
“I don’t know if Boone could flip a switch and become that guy overnight and retain any credibility,” Cone said. “That’s not who he is.”
Counterargument No. 2 says the bad-cop personality, the kind fans hunger for on social media, no longer exists in baseball. Brewers manager Pat Murphy pulled it off in Milwaukee — and took his team to a world championship. But there’s no one else like him.
Advertisement
“I understand the argument, but it’s a bygone era,” Cone said. “How many times do we see managers snap in press conferences anymore? Fights between managers and players? Those days are totally over. You can yearn for that all you want. You want to bring in a hard ass to play a role? Ok, maybe. But the players are going to see right through that.
“There’s going to be a credibility issue with that. It has to be natural. It has to be organic.”
MORE BY BOB KLAPISCH
Advertisement
Yankees may already be preparing for life after Aaron Boone | KlapischNov. 12, 2026, 10:07 a.m.
That idea brought Cone to an overarching verdict on the ’26 season. It was frustrating, but not disastrous — provided fans account for the obstacles the Yankees faced all summer.
“I think not having Judge was the difference,” Cone said. “I mean, the Yankees didn’t have their best players and they still made a decent run. It’s really hard to find position players (at the trade deadline) and Cashman did the best he could. He went outside the box with (Luis) Garcia Jr. He actually gave them a chance.
“You have to remember Judge and (Giancarlo) Stanton were supposed to be the firewall against left-handed pitching. I know people don’t want to hear excuses. I get that. But it’s the truth. It was a decent run.”
Read the original article on NJ.com. Add NJ.com as a Preferred Source by clicking here.
