A new initiative wants to guarantee that Switzerland’s planned electronic identity scheme stays voluntary, over fears it will eventually become compulsory given it will be necessary for many services.
Switzerland’s e-ID has not launched yet, but opponents are seeking constitutional protection against its compulsory use, such as the “Digital yes, but freely chosen” initiative, launched this November.
Its organisers currently have until May 17th 2028 to collect 100,000 signatures to push it towards a public vote.
READ ALSO: Why the introduction of Switzerland’s e-ID is being delayed
The campaign follows a close referendum in September 2025, when 50.39 percent of voters backed the new e-ID law, and its organisers want to ensure a campaign promise: “A freedom that we cannot exercise in everyday life is not a freedom,” said Roland Bühlmann, co-president of Nova, an association founded a month ago to support the proposal.
What is the Swiss e-ID?
The e-ID is official digital proof of identity stored in the federal government’s swiyu wallet app, and is intended as a free addition to the physical identity card, not a replacement.
It is available for people living in Switzerland, not just Swiss citizens, and applicants will need a valid Swiss identity document or a Swiss-issued foreigner’s identity card.
Data protection is central to the government’s current case, and unlike the first proposal that was rejected in 2021, the new system will be issued and operated by the state and not private companies.
The government says data stays on the user’s phone, and only the information needed for a particular check is disclosed, such as an age check, which would confirm someone is over 18 without revealing their date of birth.
READ ALSO: What is Switzerland’s e-ID and will you need it?
Daniel Säuberli, president of the Digital Identity and Data Sovereignty Association, says that Switzerland must ensure users stay in control of their data and the wallet app preserves privacy. Lawyer Martin Steiger, a digital law specialist who opposed the 2021 version but later backed the revised proposal, told SRF that if all the earlier criticisms had been addressed, there was no reason to reject the new solution.
Voluntary now, but will it always be?
The Federal Office of Justice says there is currently no general obligation to obtain or use an e-ID, but its FAQ adds an important qualification: if specific legislation requires e-ID for a particular public service, that service could become digital-only. Otherwise, it states that an analogue form alternative must remain available.
So, could Parliament actually make it compulsory without changing the Constitution? In principle, yes. The government says a change in legislation would be needed, but a significant restriction of fundamental rights must have a proper legal basis, serve a public interest and be proportionate under Article 36 of the Swiss Constitution.
There would also be a political hurdle, and new federal legislation can be challenged through an optional referendum (this would require 50,000 valid signatures within 100 days, or a request from eight cantons, after which the issue goes to a nationwide vote).
Either way, there is currently no general mandatory-use requirement, nor does the government announce a plan to introduce one. The possibility is narrower: that a future parliament could legislate to require e-ID for particular services, subject to legal and political scrutiny.
Could the concerns become real?
Digital-only services could make worries about exclusion more pressing, particularly if analogue alternatives become slower or harder to access. A post-vote gfs.bern survey found 61 percent of respondents agreed e-IDs could lead to fewer analogue services and disadvantage people who are less comfortable with this kind of digital technology.
More identity checks could create pressure to collect personal data, but that is not an automatic consequence of e-IDs; it depends on the law, safeguards and how organisations use the system. In SRF’s non-representative reader discussion, one commenter said people who did not want an e-ID in the future should be guaranteed they would not be forced to use one.
For now, a blanket requirement looks unlikely, as there is no proposal to make e-IDs compulsory for everyone, and the government says it should remain voluntary. The more realistic question is whether individual services could become digital-only over time. As the government’s own guidance says, they could; that is the gap the new initiative seems to be trying to close.
The e-ID rollout has been delayed, with it being expected in the first half of 2027, and no firm launch date yet.
