The EU, the UK and allies in the developing world rejected what they called an unacceptable deal on the future of the climate, which failed even to mention fossil fuels, in a dramatic finish to the Cop31 UN talks in Turkey.
The proposed deal “failed to meet the moment”, said Ireland’s environment minister Darragh O’Brien, speaking for the EU. “We will not endorse a decision that does not respond to the science and that actually risks deepening the chasm between global commitments and the action required. [It] does not even mention fossil fuels.”
Our colleagues in Antalya, Fiona Harvey and Graham Readfearn, have written about the outcome here.

Simon Stiell, the executive secretary of the UNFCCC, has just held a short press conference, where he emphasised that there had been many good outcomes of the conference but also acknowledged the issues.
Asked whether the consensus based system which broke down today when several countries refused to endorse the cover decision, he said: “That is the process we have, that is the process that got us through Paris and the progress made since, so it has worked.”
However, pressed further by a reporter who said that it may have worked in the past, but clearly did not work here, he conceded: “It certainly fell short today, but there are two stories to be told here.” He reminded reporters that this was a technical cop, and a significant number of the 160 agenda items were passed.
However, he said: “In terms of reform there has been a lot of discussion over the last couple years over the process … The conversation about how the process is to evolve moving forward is a live conversation.” And he said that he was engaging with parties around those challenging questions.
Lord Nicholas Stern, who wrote a landmark economic review of the impact of climate change for the UK government back in 2006, is searching for the positives. He points out that there were also positive developments in Turkey and says:
“We should now focus on the year ahead and work to strengthen shared commitment and to re-establish confidence in the multilateral process. We should remember that a valuable agreement was reached at the COP16 summit in Cancun, Mexico, in 2010 a year after disagreement in Copenhagen at COP15.
“The COP32 summit in Addis Ababa will provide a significant opportunity for the world to come together again to chart a new pathway for economic development and growth, particularly in Africa.”
Reaction to the failed cover decision and other key agenda points continues to pour in.
Ann Harrison, climate justice policy advisor at Amnesty International, said:
Countries from across regions were right to reject the colossal betrayal that the COP31 co-presidencies tried to pass off as climate action. They resisted a polluters’ charter designed to protect corporate profits while sacrificing people and the planet. They refused to accept a deeply unjust text that failed even to name fossil fuels while opening the door to risky technologies that could prolong their use.”
Mark Watts, executive director of C40 Cities, said:
This is one of the darkest hours in the history of climate negotiations and Cops cannot go on like this. The world needs braver leadership and urgent action. The era of overshoot has no room for failed climate diplomacy anymore. Every Cop must deliver collective action to accelerate the transition away from fossil fuels and address the most severe impacts of climate breakdown.
Today the Cop of Antalya failed to do that. The lack of courage by too many at Cop31 is not only undermining multilateralism, but, in the face of Super El Niño and worsening long-term climate conditions, it is costing lives.”
Teresa Anderson, the global lead on climate justice at ActionAid International, said:
Temperatures are rising, impacts are rising, but support for climate-hit countries is shrinking. The EU’s refusal to allow real progress on adaptation finance means that harvests will fail when they might have thrived. Buildings will collapse that could have withstood storms. People will drown because they didn’t get a flood alert. Millions of people will be left to deal with hunger, destruction and death that could have been avoided if rich countries cared about humanity’s future.
While the EU’s standing up to a text weak on fossil fuels has helped its reputation in this space, its self-appointed crown of climate leadership sits crookedly. The success of climate negotiations cannot be judged on carbon dioxide alone. Until wealthy polluting countries can stop seeing climate finance as a zero-sum game, climate talks will fail in their job of keeping humanity safe from rising temperatures.”
Reaction is also coming in from scientists based in the UK.
Prof Martin Siegert, University of Exeter, said:
“This could be, strangely, good news for the climate process. A line has been drawn, where international agreement can only proceed if there is clear agreement that fossil fuels need to be transitioned away from as soon as possible. The science, which is so obvious, demands this. To agree to anything less would be more of a disaster than the failings of COP31. It doesn’t mean the end of the COP process – but a resetting is needed so that it focuses on firm action to reduce global emissions, to transition to renewable energy and electrification, and to do all this urgently within a fair and just framework.”
Prof Mark Maslin, Professor of Climatology, UCL, said:
“This is probably the worst COP ever – all because fossil fuel producing countries refuse to allow the fundamental cause of climate change – namely fossil fuels – to be mentioned in the final agreement. Fossil fuels were first mentioned in COP26 in Glasgow and at COP 28 in Dubai the agreement stressed the need to transition away from the using fossil fuels. But since then, Saudi Arabia and Russia with occasional support from India, China and USA have watered down or blocked ever attempt to get global agreements on how to decarbonize the world economy. This is geopolitics playing with the lives off millions of people and the fate of the global environment.”
Prof Ali Mashayek, Department of Earth Sciences, University of Cambridge, said:
“The collapse of COP31 reflects a rift that has been widening for years. One side holds that fossil fuels are a given and we should simply get on with renewables and adaptation. The other insists we must confront decarbonisation head-on, however painful. That rift was bound to surface, and forcing an agreement nobody believes in would not have helped. You cannot solve a problem without naming its root cause. Climate impacts are already here and worsening fast. We can no longer afford flimsy, non-binding deals produced by exhausting annual marathons. COPs have achieved a great deal, but we now need serious, efficient action and honest messaging. This failure could be the precursor to exactly that.”
Australia’s climate change minister, Chris Bowen, has just spoken to reporters outside the plenary room. He says he hasn’t slept for three days.
“Unfortunately we were unable to reach agreement on a cover decision and that’s very disappointing,” he said.
“Ultimately looking back many parties who are people of good faith had very strong red lines on a couple of key issues and despite many many attempts on reflection those red lines were not able to be met.”

He thanked his staff for their efforts. “Australia left nothing on the field,” he said, but the red lines they had tried to negotiate were “unbridgeable”.
He said one key red line was the language around the transition away from fossil fuels.
“Some parties insisted if it was mentioned, they would veto,” he said.
“Fossil fuels – we tried to strike a balance,” he said. “In the end it wasn’t enough… I would have been happy with transition away from fossil fuels being in the text, but that was not going to get support from parties. Given it’s the existing position of [previous] Cops… parties couldn’t live with that.”
He said “in the real world” the transition away from fossil fuels was inevitable and was irreversible, and happening at speed.
The electrification target, which was in the unadopted Antalya Pact, had a lot of support, he said, and it was not a deal breaker.
The UN secretary-general Antonio Guterres – right at the end of his term of office, has sent out a statement on the conference:
“I am deeply disappointed that COP31 has ended without consensus on an overarching outcome. I share the very profound frustration of all those who expected governments to rise to the moment the climate crisis demands.”

He doesn’t comment on the decision by countries to reject the text, but does say: “At COP28 in Dubai, all countries agreed to transition away from fossil fuels in a just, orderly and equitable manner. The task now is to accelerate that transition, finance and deliver it.
“I welcome countries coming forward with concrete plans to do so.’
Guterres has many times singled out fossil fuels for their role in the climate crisis.
Mohamed Adow, director of the thinktank Power Shift Africa, says,
“This has been the worst ever COP and its collapse needs to be a wake up call for the world.
Rich nations and polluting governments cannot keep arriving empty-handed and expecting a carefully worded declaration to get them off the hook.
COP31 was a ghost COP, and its lack of progress will haunt the climate vulnerable.
Despite progress in recent years agreeing to transition away from fossil fuels in 2023 and a promise to triple adaptation finance in 2025, this year everything ground to a halt. At a time when climate breakdown is only getting worse, this is unforgiveable.
Previous COP achievements show that the multilateral process is not to blame, it is the countries blocking progress on finance to accelerate climate action which that are ultimately responsible.”
Jasper Inventor, head of COP31 Greenpeace Delegation, says:
“We came to COP31 to end fossil fuels, not promote them and extend their lifeline. It’s bitterly disappointing to leave without a clear outcome or a credible pathway to end fossil fuels. We stopped a bad deal that favours fossil fuels, but leaving without a deal is still a failure for communities on the climate frontlines. As always, it is the world’s most vulnerable communities who bear the consequences of this failure. We’ve run out of time to avoid overshoot, but we can still keep 1.5°C alive.”
Tuvalu’s climate minister, Maina Talia, is now speaking. “There is significant work ahead of us”, he says, adding that we must transition away from fossil fuels in a way that is just. “Tuvalu cannot do this alone.”

China experts were critical of the approach taken by the presidency, and suggested that China could have been allowed to play a larger role.
Li Shuo, Director of the China Climate Hub at the Asia Society Policy Institute, said: “COP31 should have advanced global climate cooperation despite an increasingly difficult geopolitical landscape. Instead, Antalya represents a major setback for multilateral climate diplomacy — the most significant failure since Copenhagen.
“China may have seemed a quiet player at COP31, but its presence is increasingly self-assured and influential. As the global climate agenda faces mounting geopolitical and economic headwinds, Beijing is providing continuity and stability within the multilateral system. Unfortunately, the COP31 Presidency did not effectively deploy China’s discreet power in the chaotic final stages of the negotiations.”
Kate Logan, Director of China Climate Hub and Climate Diplomacy at the Asia Society Policy Institute, said: “COP31 suffered in the hands of a disorganized presidency and stark geopolitical divides. With the US still sitting out and the EU facing down populism, China emphasized managing expectations and upholding multilateralism. While Beijing’s unique positioning enables it to forge alignment where few others can, China remained hesitant to step into a higher-profile role as consensus started to crumble.
“As the world’s dominant producer of clean technologies, China’s economic interests are increasingly intertwined with the objectives of climate talks. Officials highlighted how Chinese clean technologies are reducing emissions globally but trade protections raise costs and slow implementation, reflecting Beijing’s persistent frustration with tariffs that inhibit the free flow of clean tech. China’s $15 billion renewable energy deal with host Türkiye on the sidelines of COP31 shows how Beijing is advancing progress in the real economy, even if not necessarily captured by formal negotiations.”
Reaction to the breakdown of the talks, and the rejection of the key text, are flowing in from NGOs and campaigners.
Asad Rehman, chief executive of Friends of the Earth, said:
“After decades of broken pledges and hollow commitments, an agreement built on yet more empty promises would have been unforgivable and no substitute for the transformative action we urgently need. So the dramatic rejection of the Presidency’s final text by some, though underscoring the lack of consensus that’s been reached, restores some level of faith in its recognition that a deal of this calibre is no deal at all.”
He added:
“What matters now is not when governments reconvene, it’s how they do so. The world doesn’t need more meetings with wooly commitments. We need global governments, including the UK, to come back to the negotiating table ready to deliver. That means cutting emissions fairly at home, transitioning our economies in a way that leaves no one behind, and providing the public climate finance so desperately needed to protect people, livelihoods and our planet from unimaginable harm.”
Ani Dasguputa, president and CEO of the World Resources Institute, said:
“The hollow outcome at COP31 was a failure of political leadership, not a failure of the Paris Agreement. When narrow national interests override collective responsibility to confront the climate crisis, the entire world pays the price. Climate summits are not stages for posturing; they require every country to roll up their sleeves and do the hard work of finding ambitious common ground.
At a time when the science could not be clearer, it is indefensible that countries could not agree on even mentioning fossil fuels, the primary driver of climate change. The science has long settled this question – it’s time for the politics to catch up.”
Countries are still taking it in turns to speak in the plenary room. Despite a lack of consensus over the cover decision, Canada and others such as Fiji have said they want to continue discussions about oceans and strengthening the Cop process itself.
Canada concluded its statement saying “multilateralism is essential”.
The EU, the UK and allies in the developing world rejected what they called an unacceptable deal on the future of the climate, which failed even to mention fossil fuels, in a dramatic finish to the Cop31 UN talks in Turkey.
The proposed deal “failed to meet the moment”, said Ireland’s environment minister Darragh O’Brien, speaking for the EU. “We will not endorse a decision that does not respond to the science and that actually risks deepening the chasm between global commitments and the action required. [It] does not even mention fossil fuels.”
Our colleagues in Antalya, Fiona Harvey and Graham Readfearn, have written about the outcome here.

Although parties are still speaking in the plenary hall, discussion is now swirling around the final outcome of the talks. The presidency has headed out to the hall to speak to the press, and has confirmed that there will be no new draft cover decision. There is a lot of confusion about the next steps here.
The talks have now all but collapsed. A number of side deals will be passed, but the number of rejections of the core deal continue to mount.
