According to Crotchfelt family lore, Zach’s great-grandfather was scouted by and signed with the St. Louis Cardinals, playing for their Class AAA farm club back in the day. Perhaps in a few generations, Zach’s great-grandchildren will be telling stories at blurnsball games themselves about how their ancestor played baseball with the New York Mets. A local kid, Crotchfelt was born in Neptune and grew up in Jackson, attending Jackson Memorial High School. The left-hander was a three-year letterwinner there, missing the 2020 season due to the COVID-19 pandemic. In total, he posted a 1.38 ERA in 117.2 innings, allowing 53 hits, walking 60, and striking out 220; in his junior year in 2021, he posted a 0.85 ERA in 41.1 innings, allowing 16 hits, walking 23, and striking out 76, and in his senior year, 2022, he posted a 1.07 ERA in 65.1 innings, allowing 33 hits, walking 30, and striking out 130.
The southpaw created a bit of buzz among scouts and evaluators, and many considered him one of the best draft-eligible prospects from New Jersey available in the 2022 MLB Draft, but his name was not called because he had a strong commitment to Auburn. Head coach Butch Thompson utilized the freshman quite a bit when he arrived on campus for the 2023 season, initially utilizing him as the team’s Sunday starter before shifting him into the bullpen for the rest of the season. Appearing in 17 total games, making 6 starts, the left-hander had trouble putting things together, posting a 5.62 ERA in 41.2 innings, allowing 41 hits, walking 25, and striking out 45. Injuries unfortunately marred his sophomore season and limited him to just 7 appearance, where he pitch 7.1 innings and allowed 5 runs on 10 hits and 6 walks, with 10 strikeouts.
Advertisement
Crotchfelt supplemented his innings load by pitching for the Bourne Braves of the Cape Cod Baseball League that summer, appearing in 8 games and posting similar results to his time on the mound with Auburn. Also that summer, the left-hander entered the NCAA transfer portal that summer and left Auburn, transferring to Texas Tech, ending his Tigers career with a 5.69 ERA in 49.0 innings of work, allowing 51 hits, walking 31, and striking out 55. His time with the Red Raiders was unfortunately for him more of the same. Appearing in 13 games and making 1 start, he posted a 9.17 ERA in 17.2 innings, allowing 28 hits, walking 10, and striking out 15. Eligible for the 2025 MLB Draft, the former prep stand-out did not hear his name called.
After pitching for the Wisconsin Rapids of the Northwoods League that summer, Crotchfelt once again entered the NCAA transfer portal, this time transferring to Troy University. The senior had his best year as a collegiate pitcher and was a big reason the Trojans had a storybook season, making their first-ever College World Series. Pitching out of the bullpen as a multi-inning fireman, the left-hander posted a 3.49 ERA in 67.0 innings over 29 appearances, allowing 66 hits, walking 23, and striking out 81, establishing career-bests in virtually every pitching category.
The 6’3”, 220-pound left-hander throws from a three-quarters arm slot with a loose, easy arm. He hides the ball well and pushes off the mound with good extension, and while his mechanics don’t have any obvious injury red flags, the crossfire in his arm can be detrimental for his command and control. Crotchfelt utilizes a three-pitch mix that includes a four-seam fastball, changeup, and curveball. As a consequence of primarily being a reliever, he heavily leans on his fastball, with his other pitches still being very undeveloped for a college senior.
The southpaw’s fastball sits in the low-to-mid-90s, reportedly hitting as high as 97 MPH. Thanks to its spin rates and the left-hander’s arm slot, the pitch has some run and rising life and has been most effective up in the zone.
Advertisement
His changeup sits in the low-to-mid-80s, occasionally flashing quality depth and occasionally lacking much movement at all. Crotchfelt struggles with telegraphing the pitch, slowing up his arm when throwing the pitch. His curveball sits in the mid-to-high-70s, and like his changeup, the pitch occasionally flashes sharp 11-5 bite and other times simply floats into the zone.
